Print Print

Your Guide To Restraint And Seclusion


Text Size  A  A

A scathing report released one year ago brought unprecedented attention to the use of restraint and seclusion tactics in schools, documenting rampant examples of abusive and even deadly practices primarily involving special education students.

Now Congress is set to consider legislation this year to institute the first-ever federal oversight regulating these tactics. Meanwhile, a handful of states have made changes in an effort to promote student safety. (Read all of Disability Scoop’s coverage of restraint and seclusion >>)

Yet, for students who enter classrooms everyday, the battle is far more personal. Relatively few protections are in place in most states and consideration of the pending federal legislation will take time. That means parents and students themselves must be on the watch, says Curt Decker, executive director of the National Disability Rights Network, which issued the initial report last January and is currently preparing a follow up report.

Don’t condone it

Most importantly, Decker says, don’t give schools a free pass.

“The IEP should not contain any sanction of seclusion and restraint,” he says. “It’s not proper programming when you have to accept a restraint or a seclusion methodology in order to keep your kid in an integrated classroom.”

Rather, it is the purpose of the IEP meeting to establish appropriate programming and positive behavior supports designed to avoid severe behavior problems, Decker says.

If a child’s IEP currently includes provisions for restraint or seclusion, now is the time to request that such tactics be stripped from the plan. Should the federal legislation pass as it’s currently proposed, such measures will not be allowed in IEP plans anyway.

Watch for the signs

In most cases, parents have no idea that their child is experiencing restraint or seclusion at school. So, even if your child’s IEP doesn’t mention the techniques, that doesn’t mean school staff aren’t employing them.

Keep a keen eye for signs of disciplinary measures gone wrong, especially if you’re dealing with a child who can’t tell you what’s going on at school. Pay attention if a child is nervous about school, refuses to go or is acting out in any way.

“A lot of parents realize that their child was restrained or secluded 85 times before they even found out about it,” Decker says. “If the parents walk into the classroom and the kid is tied to a chair, then yeah, that’s pretty obvious, but too many parents just don’t even know this is happening.”

Look for assistance

If you do suspect trouble, know your rights. The protection and advocacy system, or P&A, in almost every state offers a brochure or manual on restraint and seclusion rules, Decker says. Fellow parents, local parent training centers and other advocacy organizations are also good places to turn for assistance. (Find your state’s P&A >>)

Currently, 17 states have no laws or policies regarding restraint and seclusion in schools. And even in states where regulations exist, the level of restriction varies. (Find out where your state stands >>)

Use the IEP process

Present any concerns to your child’s teacher and other school staff. Then, request records pertaining to your child and demand that school staff document any use of restraint or seclusion, Decker says.

When you are noticing problems, it’s important to trigger the IEP process to examine what’s wrong with the child’s program as a whole that’s leading to behavior issues.

“The whole IEP process is built on the premise that if the child is not doing well – either not meeting the goals or acting out – then it’s a failure of the program,” Decker says. “Don’t accept some kind of physical restraint as the answer to the problem.”

More in Education »

Search Jobs

Post a Comment

Disability Scoop welcomes comments, though only a selection are published. In determining which comments will appear beneath a story, we look for submissions that are thoughtful and add new ideas or perspective to the issues addressed within the story. Please keep your remarks brief and refrain from inserting links.

Comments (4 Responses)

  1. Lynne Adams says:

    If a parent has prohibited in writing the use of restraint or seclusion, does the school still have the right to physically restrain a student?

    I’m a special education advocate in Massachusetts and we have pretty good laws regarding physical restraint, but I couldn’t find anything prohibiting the use of restraint due to parent rights.

  2. nikki says:

    My son is in frist grade and this is his forth school his frist school only allowed him there for 40 min his second and thrid school called me all the time to pick him up I have lost my job my house and I am now trying to get on my feet he just started his new school a week ago and on thrusday he came home with bruises on his ARM and back and he was put in there so called quiet room 4 times this room is the size of a closet with no windows or air he said it was very hot and he could not breath it is not in his iep for restrains and he does not have a behavior plan what should I do

  3. Jeffrey Chan says:

    A national legislation is critical to ensuring safeguarding the rights of people with disabilities. The laws must have “grunt” and provide solutions too. See Australia ‘s state of Victoria disability legislation on the role of the Office of Senior Practitioner as an exemplary legislative model.

  4. megan says:

    I agree that restraint can be overused. I must say however when children come to school with severe mental disabilities or severe mal adaptive behaviors that other children and staff can be in danger of the outburst from a child with mental illness. I have seen desks tossed over, shelves emptied, kicking biting urinating spitting from a child when a simple request is made and they did not want to comply. What about the safety of others? Behavioral methods work on children whose minds work normally. Teachers are responsible to create citizens of the society. What are we teaching if when a student has an outburst of anger and is then released of any responsibility? they then learn I don’t have to do anything I don’t want to do I can play video games or sleep instead of participating in learning. Some of these kids also bring a variety of weapons…knives, lighters etc. again I ask what about the safety of those around students with poor judgment (for whatever reason) Many who are making the rules would be the first to say WHY did you not protect my child? when a child is injured??

Copyright © 2008-2015 Disability Scoop, LLC. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions | Reprints and Permissions