In a reversal, a federal appeals court now says that a girl who inherited fragile X from sperm her mother purchased from a sperm bank cannot sue under product liability law.

Genetic tests attribute Brittany Donovan’s fragile X diagnosis to sperm her mother Donna Donovan purchased from a sperm bank in 1995. Donna Donovan wanted to sue the sperm bank on behalf of herself and her daughter — now age 14 — because she had been assured prior to the purchase that all sperm donors were subject to screenings and genetic testing.

Last year a court sided with the Donovans, allowing their lawsuit to move forward in what was considered a first of its kind decision.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

But now a federal appeals court is dismissing the claim, ruling that allowing the lawsuit to go forward would suggest that a person can sue for “wrongful life,” reports The Legal Intelligencer. To read more click here.